On Dairy
Categories: Nutrition

4add / read
comments

posted by:  

Full disclosure -- I bought these on the way home from the gym on Day 30

On the Paleo diet, dairy is typically to be avoided. However, if you’ve eliminated it for 30 days and choose to reintroduce it to experiment and see how you handle it, what’s the best way to go about it?

First of all, you want to stick to grass-fed sources. Since the ranchers who bother to allow their cows to graze are typically quite ecologically conscious, this will likely ensure you are not adding in hormones, high amounts of omega-6 and possibly gluten or other contaminants endemic to the grain-chowing cows trapped in feedlots. (Note: your mileage may vary. Just like there are grass-fed, but not grass-finished sources of beef, dairy can be as sketchy. It pays to do your research.)

Secondly, you should go first with dairy fat sources. Ghee (clarified butter) has the vast majority of milk solids removed, leaving behind the benefits of the nutrients in the fat. Heavy cream and (unclarified) butter can often also be tolerated well by most people. Raw cream would be preferred, but is quite costly and often hard to find.

Last of all would be fermented dairy, such as yogurt and kefir. Due to the fermentation, the lactose (milk sugars) is removed. Again, these should be the full-fat versions of these items. Hopefully once you have started to walk the Paleo path, you have realized that dietary fat is not the demon the misguided food pyramid would have you think it is. Nothing makes me sadder than seeing someone eat something good like Fage yogurt, but they go with the non-fat version. *le sigh* Stephan over at Whole Health Source had a great post on this:

The fat is where the vitamins A, K2, E and D are. The fat is where the medium-chain triglycerides, butyric acid and omega-3 fatty acids are. The fat is where the conjugated linoleic acid is.

With dairy, milk is the gray area. If you are trying to put on size, it can be a powerful ally. Again, you definitely want to stick to pastured milk and you really want the raw variety (non-pasteurized). Why? There are beneficial enzymes present in the milk that get destroyed during the high temperatures of the pasteurization process. One of these is lactase, which is necessary for the digestion of lactose.

Of course, if you are trying to lose fat, the powerful insulin response that milk provides is not your friend. Insulin is the great storage hormone and you want to keep this under control when fat loss is your goal.

Due to the insulin spike from sugars along with that of dairy, it should be plainly obvious that ice cream is one of the biggest whammies. Use with extreme caution as this can run you off the rails in a hurry.

Hopefully this along with Ruth’s post about making better choices can guide you as you shed the strictness of the 30 day challenge.


WOD 05.05.11

Gymnastics WOD

4 Responses to “On Dairy”

Alia
May 5, 2011 at 9:50 AM

That is very interesting. I actually bought that same HWC yesterday as well. Although, drinking it this morning I didn’t taste the same as I recalled all of 30 some odd days ago. I don’t like it as much as just black coffee. Kind of cool to see what dairy exclusion has done to me.

Thanks to the trainers and my buddy Jake for the support. =) It be cool to hear about other people experiences reintroducing certain foods over the next few weeks.

JT
May 5, 2011 at 3:58 PM

Time to get huge on dairy! Seriously though, one big side effect of not having ice cream for 30 days: your spouse will lose weight.

I actually cut out coffee for the 30 day challenge as well. I fantasized about it for like 3 weeks during the challenge, but the cravings ceased. First day after the challenge I made myself a cup of coffee, drank half and poured the rest out. I think I kicked the habit!

Marcus
May 5, 2011 at 4:09 PM

I’m not gonna lie, I was seriously craving the heavy cream in my coffee the whole month. Now that I have it, it doesn’t quite live up to the memory. I’ll probably buy one more pint to see if this was a bad carton or not.

Holley
May 5, 2011 at 6:32 PM

That’s how I was when I was getting away from sugar and flavored half and half in my coffee. I feel like with coffee, anyone who drinks it often enough will eventually learn to like it black…heavy whipping cream is just the last step. I haven’t learned to appreciate black coffee yet, but I put less and less HWC in every week.